A couple of hours ago we posted about an op-ed by Mira Bar-Hillel, titled ‘I dated Ehud Olmert once. His ambition stood out, but the corruption was yet to come‘, which included two errors:
First, she got the date of Ariel Sharon’s coma wrong.
More significantly, Bar-Hillel greatly inflated the casualty figures from the 2008-09 war in Gaza. Here’s the original passage:
he [Olmert] ordered the molten lead attack on Gaza in December 2008, which again left over 1,000 Palestinian civilians dead,
As we noted, even B’tselem (the NGO which has one of the highest casualty tallies) didn’t claim that the three-week conflict between Israel and Hamas “left over 1,000 Palestinian civilians dead”. While other sources (including, quite tellingly, Hamas) place the civilian casualty figures dramatically lower, B’tselem has claimed that 773 of the 1387 Palestinians killed “did not take part in hostilities”.
Shortly after contacting Indy editors and alerting them to the errors, we noticed two changes:
First, the date of Sharon’s coma was corrected.
However, though there was a second change, it was not at all sufficient. They merely changed this…
Two years later, he ordered the molten lead attack on Gaza in December 2008, which again left over 1,000 Palestinian civilians dead…
Two years later he ordered the molten lead attack on Gaza in December 2008, which again left nearly 1,000 Palestinian civilians dead..
So, do they accept B’tselem’s figures, or don’t they? If they do, then are we to believe that 773 is “nearly 1000″?
Finally, it’s important to note that though newspaper editors (at the Guardian and elsewhere) who respond positively to our correction requests typically explain the revision or acknowledge it somewhere on their site, the changes to Bar-Hillel’s op-ed were not acknowledged or explained via an email, nor noted by Indy editors anywhere on the page.
- Report: The Independent Columnist Mira Bar Hillel Wrong on EU Anti-Semitism Definition Repudiation (algemeiner.com)
- Indy columnist who “fears Jews” again smears the Jewish State (cifwatch.com)
- Antisemitic reporter Mira Bar-Hillel pens op-ed (on antisemitism!) for The Independent (cifwatch.com)
- Is Mira Bar Hillel prejudiced against Jews? “Alas, yes.” (cifwatch.com)