Guardian smears Israel with a wild Palestinian accusation

Moreover, the apparent credulity of the journalist and his editor in the face of Samara's wild claim that soldiers considered shooting him for no particular reason - or that the army would have blown up his family's house if he complained - is staggering, and provides another example of how the caricature of Israeli malevolence is ingrained in the Guardian imagination.

A Guardian article by freelance journalist Carlton Reid (Why cycling in Palestine is a political act”, March 10) profiled a Palestinian cyclist named Sohaib Samara, who, as an example of how cycling in the West Bank for Palestinians is a putatively “political act”, made the following claim:

On one ride [in the West Bank] when he and a friend were pulled over by an Israeli army patrol, Samara says he heard the soldiers asking, in Hebrew, whether they should shoot the pair in the arms.

“I was not afraid for myself because at the end of the day, if I’m gonna die, I’m gonna die,” said Samara. “But I was worried that if I tried to defend myself or even argue [that the soldiers] had no right to stop us, they might later blow up my family’s house.”

We tweeted the journalist to ask if he attempted to fact check the wild claim that Israeli soldiers were considering shooting him.

Reid’s reply

Our reply

Additionally, as another Tweeter noted, Reid’s explanation on why he didn’t bother fact-checking the Palestinian claim makes no sense:

Moreover, the apparent credulity of the journalist and his editor in the face of Samara’s wild claim that soldiers considered shooting him for no particular reason – or that the army would have blown up his family’s house if he complained – is staggering, and provides another example of how the caricature of Israeli malevolence is ingrained in the Guardian imagination.

Related Posts
More from Adam Levick

Telegraph headline falsely suggests Israeli anti-Muslim racism

Please read the words in this headline, accompanying a March 3 article...
Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *