Telegraph corrects article inflating stat on IDF bombing by factor of 4000

Often times when reviewing an article about Israel in the British media, a claim evokes a mental red flag not because we know for certain that it’s false, but because it just seems, on simply an intuitive level, to be extraordinarily improbable.

That was our reaction to the following sentence in a Telegraph article about efforts to locate and neutralise landmines and unexploded ordinances in Lebanon (“Deminers of Lebanon: Destroying explosives – and returning the land to its people”, Oct. 26) by Jessie Williams.

If the IDF dropped four million bombs on Hezbollah targets during the 34 day war,  that would come out to an average of over 117,000 bombs each day!

Sure enough, after researching the matter, it seemed clear that the writer conflated two separate statistics – the number of (cluster) bombs dropped and the number of sub-munitions emanating from those bombs.

Even according to figures in a deeply flawed report by the anti-Israel NGO Human Rights Watch (that the writer evidently relied upon), the IDF dropped 962 bombs during that war, not over 4 million – an error by a factor of 4,000.   The 4 million Human Rights Watch estimate relates to the number of sub-munitions – not the number of individual bombs.

Evidently, Telegraph editors responsible for publishing the article didn’t fact-check the “4 million” figure.

So, we tweeted the journalist about her incorrect figures and, to her credit, she tweeted back to thank us, and agreed to amend the sentence, which now reads:

However, contrary to professional journalistic standards, no editor’s note acknowledging the correction has been published.

Related Posts
Written By
More from Adam Levick
The Times contradicts itself on IDF attack against Hamas
An article published today (“Inside Gaza: ‘Israelis bombed a block 500 metres away...
Read More
Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. says: MikeTQ1

    Of course 4,000,000 still sounds far more than the also incorrect 962, so instead of correcting the number they corrected the text.

Leave a comment
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *