Indy promotes libel that IDF “executed” Palestinian man (Update)

Readers of a May 3 Indy  op-ed by Ramallah based academic Amjad Abu el Ezz were told that a Palestinian man named Fawaz Hamayel was “murdered” by Israeli occupation forces” last month in “cold-blooded execution” – meaning, for no reason at all.

Here’s the headline and strap line of the op-ed:

Here’s a paragraph from the piece:

This is a lie.

Fawaz Hamayel was killed in clashes with Israeli soldiers near Nablus on April 13th in the context of ongoing counter-terror actions in Beita and other northern West Bank locations in response to a wave of deadly Palestinian attacks against Israelis.  According to reports, including even in the Guardian, Hamayel was killed while participating in a violent riot, which included throwing petrol bombs at soldiers.

Even the official Palestinian Authority’s official news outlet WAFA, and Iran’s PressTV, avoided describing Hamayel’s death as a “murder” or “execution”, instead writing that he was killed during “clashes” with Israeli soldiers.  It’s one thing to say that events surrounding his death are disputed, but the op-ed’s characterisation of his death, as if it’s a fact, as a “murder” and “cold-blooded” Israeli “execution” clearly should have been flagged by editors.

The lies continue, as the Indy contributor asserts that Hamayel wasn’t affiliated with a political party or organisation.

Again, even the Guardian acknowledged that this isn’t true, noting, in an April 22 article by Ben Lynfield, that Hamayel “played an active role as a nationalist, simultaneously as an official dealing with Jerusalem affairs in the Palestinian Authority, an activist in Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas’s Fatah organisation”.

Here’s further evidence that he was a Fatah operative:

Here’s an announcement of his death by an official Fatah account, which says that Fatah celebrates “its hero martyr”.

We’ve complained to Indy editors, asking that they correct the op-ed to note that Hamayal was a Fatah operative and to delete the fabrication that the IDF’s carried out a “cold-blooded execution”.

H/T Tomer Ilan

UPDATE, May 8: Though editors refused to correct the claim that Hamayal was “executed”, they deleted the sentence falsely asserting that he didn’t belong to “any faction or political party”.


Related Posts

Channel 4 News avoids journalism in report on al-Aqsa violence

Written By
More from Adam Levick
Israel: Defying all odds
This video, produced by, is a couple years old but still...
Read More
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *