BBC News website continues to promote narratives on Abu Akleh death

When Abba Eban died in 2002, the BBC News website reported that:

“He was also one of Israel’s most quotable politicians, among his most famous remarks the criticism of the Palestinians that they “never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity”.”

The statement misquoted by the BBC referred to chances to put an end to the Arab-Israeli conflict and since Eban made it in late 1973, some Arab nations have indeed grasped opportunities to change their relations with Israel for the better.

As for the Palestinians, the record shows that while conflict resolution (even among their own factions) is not on their list of priorities, they are in fact very good at grasping opportunities of a different kind. 

The exploitation of events such as religious holidays, anniversaries, the relocation of an embassy, an unfortunately timed chapter in a decades-long legal case or a global pandemic for the purpose of delegitimisation of Israel and/or incitement to violence on the ground should hardly come as a surprise to any veteran Middle East observer. 

So when the Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh was killed in Jenin on May 11th in circumstances that are still unclear, it was entirely predictable that such an event, like others before it, would be exploited by interested parties.

As we have documented (see ‘related articles’ below), BBC journalists adopted and amplified the narratives created by Palestinian factions, the totalitarian state Qatar and its media arm Al Jazeera in exceedingly generous cross-platform coverage of that story. Unevidenced accounts and interpretations of the event itself, along with allegations that Israel deliberately targets journalists, were unquestioningly promoted worldwide by a media organisation (and individual employees) supposedly committed to rigorous standards of accuracy and impartiality.

The second chapter in that story came on May 13th when Shireen Abu Akleh’s funeral took place in Jerusalem. When her body reached Qalandiya after being transported by ambulance from Ramallah, armed Palestinians indiscriminately discharged volleys of gunfire. The body was then transported to a hospital in Jerusalem. As reported by the Washington Post and others, the funeral arrangements had been coordinated in advance with her family:

“Her funeral route had been agreed upon by police and Abu Akleh’s family, according to media reports, and was to include the carrying of her body by hearse to a Catholic church in Jerusalem’s Old City, and then a procession to the Christian cemetery where she was to be buried in a family plot.

By noon, a crowd of several hundred formed at the entrance to St. Joseph’s Hospital in East Jerusalem, where Abu Akleh’s body had rested overnight. In the minutes before the procession was due to leave the hospital, several dozen Muslim men lined up for Friday prayers, kneeling in the parking lot. Behind them, two mourners held up large floral crosses. Then the crowd gathered, with Palestinian flags waving. […]

But a group of men in the crowd prevented a hearse from backing up to the hospital door, saying they were intent on carrying her body on their shoulders. The standoff eventually prompted Akleh’s brother, sitting on a man’s shoulders, to beseech the crowd to let the hearse through. “For God’s sake, let us put her in the car and finish the day,” he said.

“On the shoulder, on the shoulder!” people chanted, and beat the hearse with sticks until it pulled away for a second time. The crowd cheered when the men eventually dragged the coffin out on their shoulders, followed by a stretcher carrying the journalist’s blue bullet-resistant vest.

But Israeli police at the hospital gate refused to let the crowd through and, within minutes, a squad in riot gear pushed forward, setting off stun grenades and beating back the mourners with truncheons. People scattered amid a cascade of thrown bottles and rocks. At one point, Abu Akleh’s coffin lurched toward the ground, but the pallbearers managed to keep it aloft.”

On May 13th the BBC News website published three reports – two filmed and one written – on the topic of Abu Akleh’s funeral:

Filmed report without commentary:

Violence breaks out at Shireen Abu Aqla’s funeral in Jerusalem

Filmed report with commentary:

Violence at Al Jazeera journalist’s funeral procession

“Israeli police hit mourners at the funeral of Shireen Abu Aqla. The Al Jazeera reporter’s killing in the occupied West Bank has caused a surge of anger. At one point the late journalist’s coffin almost slips after police, some using batons, waded into a crowd of Palestinians gathered around it. Police say they were reacting to stones being thrown at them. Abu Aqla was shot dead while reporting on an Israeli operation. Three journalists present say she was hit by Israeli fire. Israel accepts this is possible but maintains Palestinian gunmen could have fired the fatal shot.”

Written report by Raffi Berg (includes the second filmed report):

Shireen Abu Aqla: Violence at Al Jazeera reporter’s funeral in Jerusalem

The article features an account from the scene from the BBC Jerusalem bureau’s Tom Bateman which includes the following: [emphasis added]

“The coffin was brought out of the building carried by a group of pallbearers. While the plan was for the procession to the church to use the hearse, the coffin was now being carried towards the closed gates.

What happened next was extraordinary. I was behind the packed crowd so I couldn’t see the front point of contact, but the Israeli police suddenly pushed back the crowd, including the coffin and its carriers.

They fired stun grenades towards the mourners and the press and were storming into the compound. From my vantage point – not at the front of the crowd – I saw a couple of plastic bottles being thrown back, nothing more.”

Another journalist present at the scene managed to document glass bottles and rocks being thrown at the police, as did others.

On May 14th the BBC News website published another report headlined “Shireen Abu Aqla: UN condemns killing of Al Jazeera reporter” which also included the second filmed report.

“The UN Security Council has condemned the killing of veteran Al Jazeera reporter Shireen Abu Aqla and called for an immediate probe into her death.

The move followed outcry on Friday after Israeli police hit mourners at Abu Aqla’s funeral. Police said they acted after being pelted with stones. […]

During Abu Aqla’s funeral on Friday, her coffin almost fell as police, some using batons, waded into a crowd of Palestinians gathered around it.

Footage showed a standoff between police and Palestinians gathered around the coffin in a hospital compound, before officers pushed the crowd back, with some beating and kicking mourners. Israeli police said on Saturday that an investigation into the incident was being launched.”

On May 15th a report titled “Shireen Abu Aqla: NI journalists condemn killing” appeared in the ‘updates’ section of the BBC News website’s ‘Middle East’ page.

“During Abu Aqla’s funeral on Friday, her coffin almost fell as police, some using batons, waded into a crowd of Palestinians gathered around it.

Footage showed a standoff between police and Palestinians gathered around the coffin in a hospital compound, before officers pushed the crowd back, with some beating and kicking mourners. Police said officers “were forced to use riot dispersal means” after they had been pelted with stones.”

On May 16th the BBC News website published a report by Tom Bateman headlined “Shireen Abu Aqla: Christian leaders condemn violence at reporter’s funeral” which also promotes the second filmed report from May 13th.

“The Vatican’s representative in Jerusalem has accused Israel of “brutally violating” a decades-old agreement to uphold religious freedom.

It follows Friday’s attack by Israeli police on the funeral of Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Aqla.

Officers kicked and beat pallbearers and fired stun grenades into the crowd of mourners at St Joseph Hospital.”

Bateman’s report goes on to mention a supposedly “discredited” claim but without clarifying by whom:

“The [police] force has defended its actions on the day. It has said 300 “rioters arrived” at the hospital, but this has claim been discredited. It has said some people threw stones and it was protecting the funeral plans agreed by the family to use a hearse.

It has said this is why it stopped the coffin being taken on foot from the compound. However, the family has categorically rejected the police version of events.

At Palestinian funerals, the coffin or stretcher is frequently carried by hand in public as a mark of popular tribute, especially at the passing of a notable figure. At such events it is also not uncommon for plans to change suddenly if more people want to pay their respects.”

Bateman chose to gloss over the fact that this particular “Palestinian funeral” was taking place in Israel’s capital city and that any sudden changes of plan were not conducive to keeping the peace in what was clearly potentially a very volatile situation.

In addition to presenting accounts of the short incident preceding the funeral itself that overwhelmingly promote a one-sided view of events, all the above reports once again promote the narrative advanced by Al Jazeera and others regarding the circumstances of Abu Akleh’s death.

It is of course worth remembering that no matter what the inquiry into the incident at Abu Akleh’s funeral and investigations into the circumstances of her death eventually reveal (if anything), these unabashed promotions of narratives advanced by opportunistic interested parties will remain – unamended – in the public domain of the BBC News website, just as grossly inaccurate and inflammatory accounts of another story from Jenin are still available online twenty years later.

Related Articles:

BBC WS ‘NEWSDAY’ REPORTING ON JOURNALIST’S DEATH IN JENIN

BBC NEWS WEBSITE UNCRITICALLY PROMOTES AL JAZEERA CLAIMS ONCE AGAIN

BBC RADIO 4 STICKS TO THE NARRATIVE ON AL JAZEERA JOURNALIST’S SHOOTING

BBC RADIO 4 AND THE AL JAZEERA NARRATIVE – PART ONE

BBC RADIO 4 AND THE AL JAZEERA NARRATIVE – PART TWO

BBC WS RADIO PROMOTION OF THE ‘ISRAEL TARGETS JOURNALISTS’ LIBEL

A NARRATIVE AND A LIBEL ON BBC WS RADIO’S NEWSHOUR 

 

 

 

More from Hadar Sela
Join the Conversation

4 Comments

  1. says: NORMAN COHEN

    Bel Trew at it again! https://www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/voices/shireen-abu-akleh-israel-palestine-journalist-b2084660.html

    My response:
    The same week that Shireen Abu Aklah was killed journalists in other parts of the world were also killed. However nothing was said about them and their names are not even known because as everyone knows war correspondents deliberately put themselves at risk to get a story and sometimes that can have tragic consequences which are put down to the fog of war. However when one of the protaganists is Israel and even though there is no compelling evidence to show it was an Israeli soldier who shot this journalist her death becomes “a threat to press freedom” which is hokum. Al Jazeera maintains an office in Israel from where it regularly besmirches its host country with the most outlandish claims and lies at the behest of its Qatari proprietors including without a shred of evidence that Israel assassinated Shireen. That is except for the claims of her colleagues who can hardly be described as unbiased and/or independent. Al Jazeera operates with no restrictions on their activities by the Israeli government so where is the threat to press freedom? The writer of this piece would be better off writing about the lack of press freedom accorded to her Palestinian colleagues in the Palelstinian Authority and/or Gaza who are regularlythe subject of physical attacks imprisonment and worse – if she dared.

  2. says: Neil C

    Well articulated Norman and every single word the truth. Organised rioting is the trademark of both the PA and Hamas, provocational rioting designed to engineer a response from Israel, which can be reported on by the woke media such as the BBC, Al Jaz and the Grauniad with their hallmark one sided reporting. That in essence sums up the last 75 years of the conflict. It is notable that over 2500 journalists have been killed since the gulf war but I guarantee nobody can remember any names other than this latest tragic death. It has been suggested her life was taken by a Palestinian bullet otherwise why would they not release the bullet for forensic examination by Israel? but the world keeps swallowing their lies.#defundthebbc

Leave a comment
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.