UK Media Watch prompts two corrections at The Independent

A July 3rd article in The Independent, written by Sam Masters, mischaracterized the conclusions of a UNHRC report on the Gaza war.

Here’s the relevant sentence:

A recent UN report into last year’s Gaza war found that Israel had committed war crimes.

However, if you read the text, the UNHRC report clearly only concluded that Israel (and Hamas) may have committed war crimes. 

Of interest, further in the same article, Masters uses more accurate language (“may have”) when citing UNHRC conclusions regarding Hamas’s firing of rockets at Israel.  

Interestingly, The Independent’s Jerusalem correspondent, Ben Lynfield, in a June 22nd report on the UNHRC conclusions, made this point clear.

A long-awaited UN report on last summer’s Gaza war was scathing in its criticism of Israel’s devastating aerial and ground operations, saying it may have committed war crimes

After contacting Indy editors, they revised the passage accordingly.

Additionally, we complained to editors about a claim in a July 6th article at The Independent, written by Ben Lynfield, which falsely asserted that the 50 day summer conflict with Hamas was Israel’s 2nd longest war.  We noted that the longest Israeli wars were the First Lebanon War, which lasted nearly 3 years, and The War of Attrition which also lasted about 3 years. The third longest war would be the 1948-49 War of Independence, and the fourth longest one would be last summer’s conflict.

Indy editors removed the problematic passage, and added the following addendum at the bottom:

indy change

We commend Indy editors on their positive response to our complaints.

Written By
More from Adam Levick
Guardian asks ‘expert’ what Hamas can do to “kickstart the peace process”
A story by Paul Owen on the upcoming Israeli elections and the...
Read More
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *