UK paper publishes letter suggesting Jews are repeating crimes of the Nazis

Here’s the letter published at The Journal (a Newcastle-based daily) on May 23. (“Ending Cycles of Suffering”, Features, page 33):

IT was disappointing that Covid-19 prevented the 75th VE Day celebrations, as a lot of people would have wanted to say ‘thanks’ to the surviving soldiers of WW2.

The Jewish community in Gateshead/Newcastle (letter April 24, by Shlomi Isaacson) had plans to commemorate the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Bergen Belsen, and say thanks to the North East soldiers who liberated them from a living hell; but alas this could not happen.

I appreciate the point that one has to say/show ‘thanks’ to those who have helped to liberate one from sufferings under oppressive regimes.

The experience gained should be utilized to improve the thinking and attitude of man towards his fellow man, and to cast out racial hatred. When one looks back at history, and looks at the sects that have suffered most in the past, one sees that the sufferers in the past are now repeating the atrocities!

The Jewish population suffered under the Nazi regime, yet now in Israel, Palestinians are treated as second-class citizens, having their possessions confiscated and land annexed! When will this cycle end?

Now is the time for the Jewish people to show the rest of the world that they can rise above this repetitive cycle, and that they have learnt from history. 

Mem Tahir, Kirkwhelpington

The suggestion that the treatment of Palestinians by Jews today demonstrates that Jews haven’t “learnt” from their history (that is, the systemic murder of six million Jews during the Holocaust) is morally odious, and of course evokes the Nazis-Israel analogy deemed antisemitic by the IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism.

Many of you will recall that the letter is quite similar to comments made by former Lib-Dem MP David Ward, who, in 2013, after he signed the Holocaust Educational Trust Book of Commitment ahead of Holocaust Memorial Day, wrote this on his website:

“Having visited Auschwitz twice– once with my family and once with local schools –… I am saddened that the Jews, who suffered unbelievable levels of persecution during the Holocaust, could within a few years of liberation from the death camps be inflicting atrocities on Palestinians in the new State of Israel and continue to do so on a daily basis in the West Bank and Gaza.”

Ward faced widespread and intense criticism for the remarks, including by the Holocaust Educational Trust and the CST.

As Howard Jacobson argued, such arguments – by Ward and others – leaves the Jewish people doubly damned: to the Holocaust itself and to elevated moral scrutiny as a result of it.  By this logic, Jacobson argued, “the Holocaust becomes an educational experience from which Jews were ethically obliged to graduate summa cum laude, Israel being the proof that they didn’t.”

Though editors can and should publish a wide range of views in its opinion section, letters or op-eds which include hateful rhetoric or evoke racist tropes have no place in respectable mainstream publications.

If you want to send a polite complaint to editors, here’s contact information.

Related Posts:
Written By
More from Adam Levick
Update to previous post: Guardian corrects error, places Nazareth in Israel
Our previous post (Did the Guardian forget that Nazareth is in Israel?)...
Read More
Join the Conversation


  1. says: Neil C

    Well of course this is where freedom of the press is wrong and in this case is probably breaking the law, complaints to the newspaper should be followed by complaints to the ombudsmen and complaints to the police. Such letters that blame all Jews for loss of life in a complicated conflict in another country should never see the light of day. I trust the writer with a Jewish name was verified by the newspaper as an authentic self hating Jew before publication.

  2. says: Jenny Benjamin

    Dear Editor,
    I find it unbelievable that such ideas are being published in a Newspaper, in order to denigrate Israel, the only Jewish State in the world. This Country fought against this hatred, losing thousands of young men, because they believed in justice and were against fascism and communism. Please ensure that your Staff read the history of San Remo in 1922 and the defensive war of 1948. Truth matters, especially in Newspapers where people are influenced by articles.
    Yours sincerely,
    Jenny Benjamin (Mrs)

  3. says: Molly

    Honest reporting is about printing articles which do have factual references, not personal opinions and narratives.
    Maybe your reporters do not think it necessary to research every facet of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict; but do yourselves and the most ignorant of your readers a favor and work out mathematically “genocide” or “mass murder” of the Arabs aka Palestinians by the Jews.
    In 1948 and 1967 approximately 800,000 Arabs (not Palestinians) escaped the wars, which ARABS had instigated and ran to Judea and Samaria (the West Bank of the ILLEGAL JORDANIAN OCCUPATION).
    The closest Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians ever came to the West Bank (Judea and Samaria) and East Jerusalem was through the ILLEGAL JORDANIAN OCCUPATION IN 1948 TO 1967.
    If you can do math – you will note that out of 800,000 Arabs (1964 Palestinians) now count as 6 million people.
    2 million reside in Judea and Samaria under corrupt Abbas of Fatah;
    2 million reside in Gaza under Islamic fanatics, Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
    2 million reside in Israel as full citizens with full voting rights, free speech, prayer, dress, social and health benefits.
    Honest reporters report truthful, credible news for the reader who does not know; but those of us who do know, demand an apology for your staff’s ignorance, Incitement, blood libels and dishonesty.

  4. says: AKUS

    it is clear that letters to the editor of any paper are selected for publication, and, therefore, do reflect the views the paper in question. The Journal could have chosen not to publish that letter.

Leave a comment
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *