Guardian improves article, but still misleads over “murdered” Palestinians claim

An article in the Observer – sister site of the Guardian – on Dec. 19th (‘We are family’: the Israelis sharing life and hope with Palestinians), by their new Jerusalem correspondent Bethan Mckernan, is notable for two reasons.  First, buried within the 1500 plus word (deceivingly titled) piece about settler violence is the Guardian’s sole ‘coverage’ of the Palestinian terror attack last week north of Shavei Shomron that killed 25 year old Yehudah Dimentman and injured two others.

When we say the news was buried, we mean that it was 13 paragraphs down, framed thusly:

The Palestinians can also turn to violence. Earlier this week, gunmen ambushed a car with Israeli license plates as it left Homesh in the northern West Bank, killing a 25-year-old and wounding two others.

“The Palestinians can also turn to violence” is one of those characteristically Guardian sentences, falsely suggesting, without saying so explicitly, that Palestinian terror is rare – a bug, rather than a feature.  Yet, here’s a graph showing the number of terror incidents in 2021 though November – compiled by CAMERA UK based on data from Israel’s Security Agency:

As you can see, even excluding the 2,805 attacks during the May war with Hamas, there are, on average, well over one-hundred Palestinian terror attacks each month.

The other element of the piece that stood out was McKernan’s claim that Israeli settlers murdered four Palestinian civilians in the first 10 months of 2021, citing UN data.

The UN recorded 410 attacks by settlers against Palestinian civilians and property in the West Bank in the first 10 months of 2021, including four murders, up from 358 in 2020, and 335 in 2019

However, as our colleague Tamar Sternthal demonsrated in a recent article, the claim that four Palestinians have been “murdered” by settlers, putatively based on a report by United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OHCA), is not accurate.  OCHA included the following critical information concerning its data on Palestinians killed by settlers:

Incidents involving Israeli settlers: includes attacks and alleged attacks by Israeli settlers, as well as incidents involving access prevention, and clashes following the entry of Israeli settlers into Palestinian communities. It also includes Palestinians killed or injured during attacks or alleged attacks they perpetrated against Israeli settlers. [Emphasis added.]

OCHA doesn’t make its data publicly available, and therefore their claim about the four Palestinians allegedly killed in settler violence cannot be verified. Nevertheless, the article’s failure to note that the reported figure, by OCHA’s own telling, includes Palestinian assailants falsely casts attackers as victims by claiming all four Palestinians were “murdered” by Israeli settlers.

Indeed, B’Tselem, an anti-Zionist organisation, lists two (not four) Palestinians killed in 2021 by settlers. One of the Palestinian fatalities was trying to break into a settler’s home, the other had attempted to stab the settlement security coordinator, who then shot him dead.  So, both Palestinians killed in 2021, according to B’Tslem, were assailants.

We complained to Guardian editors, asking that they either substantiate the claim – with details about the incidents – that four Palestinians were “murdered” by settlers, or retract the claim.  Though they agreed to replace the word “murdered” with “killed”, and added an editor’s note at the bottom noting the revision, it still grossly misleads by suggesting that the Palestinians assailants in question were victims of Israeli settler attacks.

Here’s the editor’s note:

Related Posts

Setting the record straight on British Jews’ support for Israel

Written By
More from Adam Levick
Former editor of Comment is Free reveals her Israel obsession in Guardian podcast
  In a previous CW post, Confronting the Guardian Ideology, the Guardian’s...
Read More
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.